Your £25K New Car Is Costing You £80K
- elimun82
- Jul 21
- 4 min read
Why Financing a New Car Isn't Financially Savvy
1. Depreciation: The Hidden Wealth Eroder
A new car loses approximately 9% of its value the moment it leaves the dealership, and around 20% in its first year.
Over five years, typical vehicles lose about 60% of their original value.
This means you’re paying interest on an asset that is (in monetary terms) depreciating fastest at the very moment you start financing it.
Car finance interest rates, also known as APR (Annual Percentage Rate), vary depending on several factors, including your credit score, the type of car, and the lender. Generally, you can expect rates ranging from 6% to 12% for those with good credit, while those with poor credit may face rates of 20% or more. According to Hippo Motor Finance, some specialist lenders may offer rates as high as 50% for borrowers with very poor credit histories.
2. Debt & Interest: Paying More to Lose Value
Take a £25,000 car: you might finance it over 5 years with, say, 6% interest. Over time, you’d pay more in interest, plus suffer the depreciation hit, effectively doubling the financial drag.
You lose equity immediately, and the vehicle's rapidly shrinking value means you're paying interest even as the car’s value plummets.
🚘 Tesla Car vs Tesla Investment
Tesla Car (Financed)
Loan Amount: £25,000
Loan Term: 5 Years (60 months)
Interest Rate: 6% APR (fixed)
Monthly Payment: £483.32
Total Paid Over 5 Years: £28,999.20
Total Interest Paid: £3,999.20
Estimated Depreciation: £15,000 (according to Kelley Blue Book – kbb.com)
Total Financial Drag Interest Paid (£3,999.20) + Depreciation (£15,000) = £18,999.20
In other words, the car buyer is £19,000 out of pocket after 5 years. They spent nearly £29,000, and are left with a car worth only £10,000.
Tesla Investment (Stock)
Let’s compare that with someone who bought Tesla stock in July 2020 for $280 (adjusted for a 3:1 stock split).
Tesla stock price – July 2020: $280
Tesla stock price – July 2025: $329
This represents a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of about 25% over 5 years.
Final Value of £25,000 Investment
£25,000×(1.25)5=£86,250
Comparison Summary
Scenario | Person A (Car Buyer) | Person B (Investor) |
Capital Used | £25,000 | £25,000 |
Outcome After 5 Years | Car worth ~£10,000 | Investment worth ~£86,250 |
Net Financial Result | −£18,999 (loss) | +£61,250 (gain) |
The difference between the net wealth of the person who bought the Tesla car and the person who bought Tesla stock is a staggering £80,000.
Takeaway
The takeaway here is not "never buy a car", it’s that you should buy intelligently, so it doesn’t cripple you financially. This brings us to the next section.
Smarter Alternatives to Buying New
A. Buy a Late-Model Used Car (3–5 Years Old)
These vehicles often hit the “sweet spot”: most depreciation has already occurred, but the car is still reliable and relatively new.
In the UK, financial experts advise buying cars that are 3–5 years old, where depreciation slows to about 15% across years three to six.
One survey showed that a 5-year-old car retains about 67% of its original value, a depreciation of only around 33% (source: Navy Federal Credit Union).
Benefits: lower upfront cost, lower insurance premiums, and less future depreciation.
B. Consider Salvage or Rebuilt Cars
Salvage-title vehicles are typically 20–50% cheaper than equivalent clean-title cars.
If you're mechanically inclined, or have access to affordable repairs, they can offer excellent value.
Important: Only buy non-structurally damaged cars. In the UK, these are Category N cars, which have no structural damage.
For example, I personally bought a Category N car for £2,500 that would normally cost £10,000. I spent £1,400 to repair it, just a small dent at the rear.
Caution: Salvage vehicles may have hidden issues, may require re-inspections, and can be more difficult to insure or resell.
Tips to Reduce Risk When Buying Used or Salvage
Save and Pay Cash
Avoid finance costs altogether. Buy only when you have saved enough. This prevents you from paying interest on a depreciating asset.
Pre-Purchase Inspection
Use a service like ClickMechanic (UK) to have an independent mechanic inspect the car before you commit to buying. This can save you thousands in repairs later.
Check Vehicle History
Always run a Carfax, AutoCheck, or HPI report to ensure the vehicle hasn’t been in major accidents and doesn’t carry outstanding finance. Clean histories help preserve value; salvage titles warrant more scrutiny.
Stick to Reliable Brands
Brands like Toyota, Honda, and some pickup trucks retain value better and tend to have longer useful lifespans, saving you money long term.
Not everyone will be buying Tesla stock, and I haven’t either, but this was simply an example to illustrate that investing in good stocks can outperform buying a new car on finance and paying interest on a rapidly depreciating asset. Stay smart out there, and don’t feel pressured to drive the latest car. Your future self will thank you, all the way to the bank.
Ask your question
Would you buy a brand new car?
Yes
No
댓글